Thesis
Identity work, belonging, and legitimacy among second-generation South Asian women : three essays on intersectional entrepreneurship
- Creator
- Rights statement
- Awarding institution
- University of Strathclyde
- Date of award
- 2026
- Thesis identifier
- T18223
- Person Identifier (Local)
- 202059272
- Qualification Level
- Qualification Name
- Department, School or Faculty
- Abstract
- This thesis examines how intersectional inequalities shape the career trajectories, identity work, and entrepreneurial legitimacy of second-generation South Asian women in the United Kingdom. Although women have increasing access to professional employment and entrepreneurial opportunities, access alone does not deliver recognition, belonging, or legitimacy. Instead, formal inclusion masks a deeper problem: women must continuously negotiate their identities within contexts shaped by intersecting gendered, racialised, and cultural power relations. This thesis conceptualises these women as intersectional ethnic entrepreneurs, individuals whose entrepreneurial experiences, identities, and negotiations are shaped by the simultaneous operation of gender, race, ethnicity, and culture across multiple life domains. Drawing on qualitative, interpretive research with seventeen second-generation South Asian women in the UK, the thesis develops a process-based intersectional account of how inequality unfolds across three interconnected domains. The three empirical essays summarised below develop an argument about how identity work, legitimacy, and belonging are continuously negotiated across organisational, entrepreneurial, and social contexts. Essay 1 examines how intersectional workplace experiences shape career trajectories and transitions into entrepreneurship. Using an interpretive, inductive approach with seventeen participants, it shows that despite formal inclusion, second-generation South Asian women experience conditional recognition, limited progression, and ongoing identity regulation within organisations. Accumulating over time, these experiences generate accumulated identity strain, which gradually weakens attachment to organisational careers and shapes decisions to move into entrepreneurship. The essay contributes by theorising entrepreneurial transition not as individual choice or opportunity pursuit alone, but also as a relational response to sustained structural conditions that made organisational careers difficult to continue. Essay 2 explores how belonging is experienced and constructed within entrepreneurial support spaces and networking environments. Drawing on fifteen qualitative interviews, it finds that access to mainstream entrepreneurial support hubs does not guarantee meaningful participation or recognition for intersectional entrepreneurs. Instead, women construct belonging actively within identity-based networks, where shared cultural, religious, and gendered experience enables trust, mutual recognition, and learning. The essay introduces the concept of constructed belonging, showing that belonging is a relational achievement produced through everyday interactions. In addition, identity-aligned support hubs helped women rebuild their sense of belonging and entrepreneurial confidence. Essay 3 investigates how women negotiate entrepreneurial legitimacy after establishing their businesses. It demonstrates that entrepreneurship does not dissolve inequality but reconfigures it. Women must continuously adapt how they present themselves across market, family, and community contexts, each of which evaluates them according to different and often conflicting expectations. The essay theorises this process as bounded legitimacy negotiation: legitimacy is context-dependent, audience-specific, and never fully secured. Moreover, identity work remains structural labour rather than individual strategy under persistent intersectional constraints. Together, these three essays build a connected argument. Intersectional inequalities define the structural conditions within which identity work occurs. Identity work is the mechanism through which intersectional entrepreneurs attempt to secure legitimacy and belonging across contexts. And legitimacy is the outcome that is always being sought, always contested, and never finally achieved. This thesis does not focus on individual struggle or resilience. Instead, it shows how systems of power such as gendered, racialised, and cultural norms shape careers and entrepreneurial experiences. For these participants, formal inclusion did not address the inequalities they faced as intersectional entrepreneurs. The thesis makes two conceptual contributions, each with two parts. The first is conditional inclusion, theorised as a dynamic cross-context mechanism, showing that inclusion itself reproduces inequality across professional and entrepreneurial domains simultaneously, producing identity regulation and accumulated strain rather than stable belonging. Its second part is accumulated identity strain, which theorises how the sustained identity work demanded by conditional inclusion gradually weakens belonging, legitimacy, and confidence in organisational careers. The second contribution is bounded legitimacy negotiation, theorised as the central experience of intersectional entrepreneurs. Its first part is constructed belonging, which shows that belonging functions as a mechanism through which participation and legitimacy are produced, rather than as an affective outcome of inclusion, and the thesis specifies the relational mechanisms through which it is constructed. Its second part is the bounded negotiation of legitimacy itself, which shows that entrepreneurship delivers partial and context-dependent empowerment rather than an escape from intersectional constraint, and operates as a relational response to sustained structural conditions. This account also extends bounded agency across time, as expectations surrounding women’s work, visibility, and ambition are inherited from the first generation and encountered before entering the workplace. As a result, the limits on agency are partly inherited rather than imposed solely in the present. The thesis offers a novel intersectional framework for understanding careers, belonging, and legitimacy that moves beyond static, single-context analyses. It positions second-generation South Asian women as intersectional entrepreneurs navigating unequal systems of recognition across their working lives.
- Advisor / supervisor
- McMillan, Carolyn
- Resource Type
- DOI
Relations
Items
| Thumbnail | Title | Date Uploaded | Visibility | Actions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
PDF of thesis T18223 | 2026-11-05 | Public | Download |