Thesis

Does accent variation affect the identification of Speech Sound Disorders in Scottish English-speaking children?

Creator
Rights statement
Awarding institution
  • University of Strathclyde
Date of award
  • 2026
Thesis identifier
  • T18030
Person Identifier (Local)
  • 202467573
Qualification Level
Qualification Name
Department, School or Faculty
Abstract
  • BackgroundAccent variation can impact the identification of Speech Sound Disorders (SSD). TheDiagnostic Evaluation of Articulation and Phonology (DEAP) is recommended to screenfor and diagnose SSDs; however, it does not contain guidance on which phonologicalfeatures may be variants of Scottish English speech.AimTo provide a list of accent variants to consider when assessing Scottish English-speaking children. To quantify the impact of misinterpretation of accent variants aserrors on the PCC score elicited from the DEAP screen.MethodSpeech samples from 273 Scottish children were analysed. Each child’s PCC score wascalculated twice: once counting accent variants as correct (Method A) and once aserrors (Method B). Multiple regression analysis was used to determine the impact ofsocioeconomic factors on PCC score.ResultsObserved processes included /t/ glottalization, “th” fronting, /?/ fronting, and /r/weakening. Fifty-three children were identified with speech errors when accent variantswere counted as correct, compared to 148 when they were counted as errors.Statistical analysis revealed significantly higher PCC scores when accent variants werecounted as correct, t(272) = 13.00, p < .001, r = .64. Method A yielded higher scores (M = 96.97, SD = 8.82) than method B (M = 94.25, SD = 9.96). Age, sex, and history of speech,language, and communication needs, significantly predicted PCC scores.DiscussionThe identified phonological features should be recognised as accent features ofScottish English rather than speech errors. These features of Scottish English may bemisclassified as speech errors when using the DEAP screen, as they do not match thetarget transcriptions and often resemble developmental errors listed in the scoringmanual.ConclusionSLTs must consider accent variation in diagnostic assessments to avoid overidentification and unnecessary intervention.
Advisor / supervisor
  • Lawson, Eleanor
  • Cleland, Joanne, 1980-
Resource Type
DOI
Date Created
  • 2025
Embargo Note
  • This thesis is restricted to Strathclyde users only.

Relations

Items