Thesis

Closing the gap between guidance and practice : an investigation of the relevance of design guidance to practitioners using object-oriented technologies

Downloadable Content

Download PDF
Creator
Rights statement
Awarding institution
  • University of Strathclyde
Date of award
  • 2019
Thesis identifier
  • T15234
Person Identifier (Local)
  • 201374135
Qualification Level
Qualification Name
Department, School or Faculty
Abstract
  • This thesis investigates if object oriented guidance is relevant in practice, and how this affects software that is produced. This is achieved by surveying practitioners and studying how constructs such as interfaces and inheritance are used in open-source systems. Surveyed practitioners framed 'good design' in terms of impact on development and maintenance. Recognition of quality requires practitioner judgement (individually and as a group), and principles are valued over rules. Time constraints heighten sensitivity to the rework cost of poor design decisions. Examination of open source systems highlights the use of interface and inheritance. There is some evidence of 'textbook' use of these structures, and much use is simple. Outliers are widespread indicating a pragmatic approach. Design is found to reflect the pressures of practice - high-level decisions justify 'designed' structures and architecture, while uncertainty leads to deferred design decisions - simpler structures, repetition, and unconsolidated design. Sub-populations of structures can be identified which may represent common trade-offs. Useful insights are gained into practitioner attitude to design guidance. Patterns of use and structure are identified which may aid in assessment and comprehension of object oriented systems.
Advisor / supervisor
  • Wood, Murray
Resource Type
DOI
EThOS ID
  • uk.bl.ethos.793468
Date Created
  • 2019
Former identifier
  • 9912727791402996

Relations

Items

Thumbnail Title Date Uploaded Visibility Actions
file details PDF of thesis T15234 2021-07-02 Public Download